Prevention of epileptogenesis-a new goal for epilepsy therapy
Contents lists available at
Pediatric Neurology
Perspectives in Pediatric NeurologyPrevention of Epileptogenesis A New Goal for Epilepsy Therapy
Sergiusz Józwiak MD, PhD Katarzyna Kotulska MD, PhD
Department of Neurology and Epileptology, The Children's Memorial Health Institute, Warsaw, Poland
Progress in epilepsy treatment in last decades of the
discharges on electroencephalography (EEG) were treated
twentieth century included a number of new antiepileptic
with oral ethosuximide from postnatal day 21 to 5 months of
drugs that were expected to reduce the number of patients
age. Early treatment with ethosuximide led to a persistent
with drug-resistant epilepsy. However, it soon became
suppression of seizures, even several months after therapy
obvious that, in spite of the improving safety of antiepileptic
withdrawal. Prolonged antiepileptogenic treatment in this
treatment, the efficacy of new agents was not much better
genetic model had a beneficial effect on white matter
than the old drugs. The number of patients with drug-
microstructure in Wistar Albino Glaxo/Rij rats as observed by
resistant epilepsy decreased little, and their outcome has
diffusion tensor imaging studies.These experiments with
not been improved.
ethosuximide and levetiracetam in genetic models seem to
The search for new therapeutic approaches and the
demonstrate that epilepsy prevention is possible and that
emergence of clinically relevant animal models of epilepsy
antiepileptogenic treatment may provide a new strategy for
led to a renewed interest in the process of epileptogenesis.
preventing epilepsy in susceptible individuals.
This cascade of molecular and cellular alterations (including
Several completed clinical trials in humans have
changes in expression and function of receptors and ion
demonstrated that administration of conventional antiepi-
channels) begins with an insult, brain injury, or genetic
leptic drugs, such as phenytoin, phenobarbital, carbamaz-
predisposition. There is often a latent period lasting weeks
epine, or valproate, in patients after traumatic brain injury
to months before the onset of seizures, followed by the
failed to prevent the development of epilepsyHowever, it
development of clinical epilepsy and its comorbidities. This
seems likely that these studies were not properly designed
latent period of epilepsy development may offer a time
to answer the question at hand, and the drugs were not
window when an appropriate medication may stop or
selected to have antiepileptogenic activity
modify the epileptogenic process.
The immature brain seems to be especially vulnerable to
Recent animal studies using the genetic models proved
seizures, but it may also be particularly susceptible to
that early (antiepileptogenic) therapeutic intervention dur-
antiepileptogenic treatment. Talos et used a rodent
ing this latent period might prevent the development of
model of acute hypoxia-induced neonatal seizures to
epilepsy. In an epileptic double mutant rat (spontaneously
determine how seizures alter mTOR complex 1 signaling,
epileptic rat; zi/zi, tm/tm) that presents recurring tonic and
absence-like seizures in response to mild sensory stimula-
behavior in later life. They demonstrated that inhibition of
tion, Yan et alused levetiracetam for three weeks before the
mTOR complex 1 immediately before and after seizures
expected time of seizure onset. Such preventative treatment
reversed an early increase in glutamatergic neurotrans-
with levetiracetam resulted in a significant decrease in the
mission and seizure susceptibility and attenuated later life
incidence of both types of seizures, indicating a disease-
epilepsy and autistic-like behavior.
modifying effecAnother genetic model of human
The impact of effective antiepileptogenic treatment on
absence epilepsy was used by Blumenfeld et alWistar Al-
the immature brain is particularly apparent in children less
bino Glaxo/Rij rats that exhibit spontaneous spike-wave
than two years of age. Clinical settings provide an especiallygood opportunity to prevent epilepsy and its comorbiditiesin some genetic or developmental defects with a high risk of
epilepsy during the first years of life. Prophylactic treatment
Received July 30, 2014; Accepted in final form August 26, 2014
with phenobarbitone of 16 infants with Sturge-Weber
* Communications should be addressed to: Dr. Jó
zwiak; The Children's
syndrome resulted in decreased epilepsy (P < 0.01) and
Memorial Health Institute; Al. Dzieci Polskich 20; 04-730 Warsaw,
mental retardation (P
< 0.05) in comparison to 21 children
treated in the standard manner (i.e., after the onset of
0887-8994/$ - see front matter Ó 2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
S. Józwiak, K. Kotulska / Pediatric Neurology 51 (2014) 758e759
clinical A similar beneficial effect of preventative
molecular (genomics, transcriptomics, proteomics, metab-
treatment has been observed in our study in infants with
olomics, epigenetics) investigations. The project has just begun
tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC). A prospective study of 14
and will last for five years.
children treated with vigabatrin due to paroxysmal activity
Prevention of epilepsy in individuals at risk or the
on EEG in the first months of life demonstrated a lower
modification of the disease outcome is one of the major
incidence of drug-resistant epilepsy and higher intelligence
United States The National Institute of Neurological Disor-
quotient score at 24 months of age compared with 31
ders and Stroke/ National Institutes of Health Epilepsy
traditionally treated children (7.1% versus 41.9%, P < 0.05;
Research benchmarks and also a research priority of the
and 92.3% versus 68.7%, P < 0.05, respectiv
European scientific community. Such a goal is particularly
The recently published "practical clinical definition of
meaningful for pediatric neurologists, the physicians who
epilepsy" made also a step forward toward anti-
are often in the optimal position to alter the natural course
epileptogenic treatment by allowing the diagnosis of epi-
of disease and improve the quality of life of their patients
lepsy after a single seizure in many situations with a
and their families.
probability of another seizure exceeding However,there are still no recommendations for pre-emptive man-
The work reported in this paper was partially supported by the 7th Framework
agement of specific groups of patients with a very high
Programme of European Commission within the large-scale integrating project
incidence of epilepsy, well recognized natural course of the
disease, and established severe epilepsy comorbidities suchas mental retardation and autism. In conditions such as TSC,Sturge-Weber syndrome, Angelman syndrome, and Rett
syndrome with an incidence of epilepsy over 60% in the firstyear of life, the antiepileptogenic treatment should be
considered before the onset of clinical seizures, when epi-
leptogenesis is early in progress.
A search of valid biomarkers to aid the identification of a
point of no return in the epileptogenesis process is a major
challenge for clinicians. In our experience with over 50 TSC
infants followed since soon after birth with video EEGs per-
formed every 4 weeks, those who developed paroxysmal ac-
determination of EEG characteristics as well as the molecular
and neuroimaging biomarkers allowing identification of chil-
dren with high risk of epilepsy is critical. Currently, such
studies are ongoing within the long-term, prospective study
evaluating clinical and molecular biomarkers of EPIlepto-
genesiS in a genetic model of epilepsyeTuberous SclerOsis
ComPlex (EPISTOP), the large-scale collaborative project
within the 7th Framework Programme of European Commu-
nity. EPISTOP is a multicenter, prospective study of epilepto-
genesis in TSC infants, starting from its latent phase before
seizures onset and extending to the development of drug-
resistance and epilepsy neuropsychiatric comorbidities. The
comprehensive analysis of possible epileptogenesis bio-
markers in EPISTOP project includes a wide range of clinical,
electrophysiological, neuroimaging, neuropsychologic, and
Source: http://www.epistop.eu/images/article/Prevention_of_Epileptogenesis.pdf
measured on a thumb, the nymph is 2mm IntroductionLyme disease was fi rst described in the USA in 1974 available from the Health Protection Agency (HPA)2 and takes its name from Old Lyme in Connecticut, Lyme Borreliosis Unit based at Southampton General where the fi rst outbreaks were noted. The illness had been known by a variety of names in Europe since the
Willdenowia 30 – 2000 The inclusion of adventive plants in the second edition of FloraPalaestina Danin, A.: The inclusion of adventive plants in the second edition of Flora Palaestina. – Willdenowia30: 305-314. 2000. – ISSN 0511-9618. Distribution maps for 19 prominent woody adventive gymnosperms, dicots and monocots, which areestablished in the Flora Palaestina area but not included in Flora Palaestina, ed. 1, are presented,showing their presence in grid areas of 5 7 5 km in Israel, and data on their introduction, habitats anddispersal modes are given in this preparatory contribution for the second edition of Flora Palaestina.